The Pinball Arcade table ratings

[Striker]

Give me a 9 for World Champion Soccer. Goes to 10 once they fix the physics.

 

[Gorgias32]

I like these ratings in general, I was just playing Bone Busters the other day and it is truly right down there with Goin' Nutz.

Hopefully Black Knight post-revamp will rise over time, it definitely doesn't belong at the #82 spot anymore.

 

[Kolchak357]

I like these ratings in general, I was just playing Bone Busters the other day and it is truly right down there with Goin' Nutz.

Hopefully Black Knight post-revamp will rise over time, it definitely doesn't belong at the #82 spot anymore.

Totally agree with every word. ^

 

[BennyJackdaw]

Can I ask a random question about Black Knight?

So far, I've only played Black Knight on the Kindle version, where it's very glitchy and the ball CONSTANTLY locks up. Is this true for other versions of Black Knight, and that may account for so many low scores for the table? Cause personally I like the table, I just don't like the glitches.

 

[Gorgar]

Can I ask a random question about Black Knight?

So far, I've only played Black Knight on the Kindle version, where it's very glitchy and the ball CONSTANTLY locks up. Is this true for other versions of Black Knight, and that may account for so many low scores for the table? Cause personally I like the table, I just don't like the glitches.

Did you play it within the last 2 months? It was fixed very recently and plays great.

 

[BennyJackdaw]

Did you play it within the last 2 months? It was fixed very recently and plays great.

Yeah. If there was a patch for it, I haven't gotten it yet, and this is the Pinball Arcade Underground version by the way.

 

[Gorgias32]

re: new Black Knight - I wouldn't expect scores to go UP with this version, but probably DOWN, at least that has been my experience - the upper area is not as exploitable to get repeated 3-ball multiballs as it used to be. It plays a lot more like real life, that is to say brutal and terrifying- when you are in the lower playfield you are always one flip and bounce away from draining.

 

[EldarOfSuburbia]

re: new Black Knight - I wouldn't expect scores to go UP with this version, but probably DOWN, at least that has been my experience - the upper area is not as exploitable to get repeated 3-ball multiballs as it used to be. It plays a lot more like real life, that is to say brutal and terrifying- when you are in the lower playfield you are always one flip and bounce away from draining.

Umm, it finally actually works? All of the sounds are in, not just a small subset? The lights all work properly? The upper playfield locks work correctly?

I've actually found my score have gone up with the new version, probably because the scoring has been fixed as well.

New Emulated Black Knight is far, far, better than Old Scripted Black Knight.

You could say it's Knight and Day....

 

[Gorgias32]

Totally agree, the new emulated BK is 1000% better than the old version

 

[BennyJackdaw]

Totally agree, the new emulated BK is 1000% better than the old version

That kind of contradicts your last post, though.

 

[EldarOfSuburbia]

That kind of contradicts your last post, though.

Having read back, I think it was supposed to mean that in-game scores were likely to go down. Not the table ratings. The table ratings should definitely get a bump.

 

[Dedpop]

You could say it's Knight and Day....

 

[Gorgias32]

Having read back, I think it was supposed to mean that in-game scores were likely to go down. Not the table ratings. The table ratings should definitely get a bump.

Yes, that's what I meant - I find the retuned version to be less exploitable and more realistic, and therefore more challenging, which is a good thing.

 

[Jiveturkey]

Left my rating.. Only gave monster bash a 10..only handed out a few 9's..like mm, Rbion,TZ, ngg,... I just can't get into the old old tables, big shot probaly my favorite out of all Of them I can think of now... Sttng I gave a 9 or 8,i stink at it,I keep those outlanes full haha.. But I can see it's a good game with rules I'd like.....
I hate the music in funhouse.. Its just Constant, I don't mind Rudy though.. Afm is 2 easy and idk the colours could have been better.. Mb is easy too but the art & music make up for it, easy doesnt mean it's no good..
Gonna update ratings once I get more familiar with some tables. Keep on pinning

 

[smbhax]

Added Fathom to the survey!

http://smbhax.com/tpatr

Last month's new table, World Champion Soccer, is in an impressive 6th place in the table! : o This has pushed Terminator 2: Judgement Day out of the top 10, into 11th place.

The Pinball Arcade table ratings
——————————
1. 9.05 — Medieval Madness
2. 8.82 — Attack from Mars
3. 8.63 — Monster Bash
4. 8.53 — Theatre of Magic
5. 8.45 — The Twilight Zone
6. 8.40 — World Champion Soccer
7. 8.25 — The Addams Family
8. 8.20 — Star Trek: The Next Generation
9. 8.15 — Tales of the Arabian Nights
10. 7.97 — White Water
11. 7.84 — Terminator 2: Judgment Day
12. 7.78 — Eight Ball Deluxe
13. 7.77 — Red & Ted's Road Show
14. 7.70 — No Good Gofers!
15. 7.69 — Fish Tales
16. 7.62 — Funhouse
16. 7.62 — The Getaway: High Speed II
18. 7.57 — Taxi
19. 7.55 — WHO dunnit
20. 7.54 — Bram Stoker's Dracula
20. 7.54 — Cirqus Voltaire
22. 7.44 — Indianapolis 500
23. 7.40 — Ripley's Believe It or Not!
24. 7.37 — Scared Stiff
25. 7.35 — Creature from the Black Lagoon
26. 7.30 — Doctor Who
27. 7.27 — Junk Yard
28. 7.22 — Jack•Bot
29. 7.21 — Cactus Canyon
30. 7.20 — Whirlwind
31. 7.15 — Paragon
32. 7.14 — No Fear: Dangerous Sports
33. 7.07 — Safe Cracker
34. 7.02 — Diner
35. 6.96 — Judge Dredd
36. 6.91 — Black Rose
37. 6.88 — High Roller Casino
38. 6.86 — The Machine: Bride of Pin•Bot
39. 6.85 — Earthshaker
40. 6.78 — High Speed
41. 6.72 — The Champion Pub
42. 6.71 — Firepower II
42. 6.71 — Swords of Fury
44. 6.70 — Pin•Bot
45. 6.68 — Hurricane
46. 6.67 — Centaur
47. 6.61 — Mary Shelley's Frankenstein
48. 6.59 — Elvira and the Party Monsters
49. 6.51 — F-14 Tomcat
50. 6.44 — Space Shuttle
51. 6.41 — Flight 2000
52. 6.39 — Black Knight 2000
52. 6.39 — Cyclone
54. 6.38 — Wipe Out
55. 6.36 — Xenon
56. 6.35 — Party Zone
57. 6.33 — Last Action Hero
58. 6.25 — Tee'd Off
59. 6.16 — Big Shot
60. 6.08 — Jacks Open
61. 6.04 — Gorgar
62. 5.98 — Cue Ball Wizard
63. 5.85 — TX-Sector
64. 5.78 — Centigrade 37
64. 5.78 — Phantom of the Opera
66. 5.75 — Firepower
66. 5.75 — Starship Troopers
68. 5.69 — Black Hole
69. 5.66 — Dr. Dude
70. 5.60 — Class of 1812
71. 5.56 — Big Hurt
72. 5.50 — Harley-Davidson Third Edition
73. 5.46 — Gladiators
74. 5.36 — El Dorado
75. 5.34 — Lights...Camera...Action!
76. 5.33 — Haunted House
77. 5.26 — Fireball
78. 5.14 — Cactus Jack's
79. 5.06 — Victory
80. 5.02 — Al's Garage Band
81. 4.82 — Genie
82. 4.78 — Rescue 911
83. 4.64 — Black Knight
84. 4.45 — Doctor Who: Master of Time
85. 4.08 — Central Park
86. 3.90 — El Dorado City of Gold
87. 3.47 — Bone Busters Inc.
88. 3.33 — Goin' Nuts
89. none — Fathom

 

[Joe Schmoe]

Well, I guess I'll throw my hat into the ratings ring. And yes, you'll probably find my tastes in Pinball to be vastly different than most other peoples':

--10 Rating--

Black Rose
Central Park
Medieval Madness
Scared Stiff
TX-Sector

--9 Rating--

Big Shot
Black Knight
Cactus Jack's
Cyclone
Dr. Dude
El Dorado
Judge Dredd
No Good Gofers!
Xenon

From 8 rating to 5 rating are waaaaay too many to list, so I'll skip over to the 4 ratings and below:

--4 Rating--

Cirqus Voltaire
Cue Ball Wizard
Dr. Who
Earthshaker
El Dorado: City of Gold
Flight 2000
Genie
High Roller Casino
Mary Shelley's Frankenstein
Phantom of the Opera
Safecracker
Star Trek: The Next Generation

--3 Rating--

The Addams Family
The Championship Pub
Creature From the Black Lagoon
Firepower
Harley-Davidson: Third Edition
Monster Bash
Rescue 911
Ripley's Believe it or Not
Terminator 2: Judgement Day
The Twilight Zone
World Championship Soccer

--2 Rating--
Starship Troopers

And if you're interested, I go into more detail on the tables in this video (keep in mind I was trying to go through them quickly and some of them I only played a few times): https://www.twitch.tv/videos/181407341

 

[wizard33]

you'll probably find my tastes in Pinball to be vastly different than most other peoples':

"Yes Yes Yes" 1 million times (especially for TZ and MB)

 

[Gorgias32]

Well, I guess I'll throw my hat into the ratings ring. And yes, you'll probably find my tastes in Pinball to be vastly different than most other peoples':
Starship Troopers

That list is kind of all over the place - I am actually interested in how you define your tastes. Some of your top rated are pretty similar to bottom rated.

I am with you on Central Park, though, that table is a ton of fun but doesn't get a lot of respect here.

 

[Silverball67]

"Yes Yes Yes" 1 million times (especially for TZ and MB)

1 zillion times: stranger than strange in some ways. el dorado and central park on top, twilight zone and mb on bottom, that's a headstand.
But well, that's your choice. Better than a community with similar tastes.

 

[Kolchak357]

I think everyone has an outlier or two. I love TX-Sector and hate STTNG. But Schmoe, you do buck the standard opinion on a great many pins. That's why it is so important to have a varied selection. It's all good.