LanceBoyle
New member
- Jul 5, 2013
- 216
- 0
I don't really understand the makeup of ratings for vid games, what exactly moves things from E to Teen. I had a conversation with Norman at FS where I argued that things said in Medieval Madness were every bit as suggestive as things said in Scared Stiff, and he agreed that MM might have slipped under the radar. I think FS was trusting that if the ROM didn't have a family mode, it must have been okay.
I should point out, I'm basing my opinions entirely on how things are viewed in the US.
If the ratings are for video games are anywhere near as screwy as they are for movies, well who knows what constitutes an 'After Dark' table. For instance, if someone smokes in a movie now, it is an automatic PG-13 unless it is being used as an argument against. You can drop a maximum of 2 F-bombs in a PG-13 movie so long as they are not used in a sexual context. "Drop the f__kin' gun!" = PG-13, while "You motherf__ker" = R. Bloody squib hits are not allowed in a PG flick, and are heavily frowned upon in PG-13. However, if you are shooting at an alien with green or blue blood, buckets of the stuff can flow. I'm not sure how accurate this is, but I had heard that kicking a person in the face while doing martial arts would get you an automatic R. The Matrix could have been PG-13 were it not for that and the use of songs with swearing in the end credits.
I look back at movies from 25 years ago that were rated PG, and many of them would be considered R now. Sixteen Candles, with swearing, teen drinking, nudity? Or Better Off Dead where a character is snorting whatever he thinks could get him high, and they show it? Beastmaster or Sheena where Tonya Roberts got nekkid for long stretches of screen time?
Point is, we may laugh at what might be considered an 'After Dark' title, but the politically correct age we live in now, who knows what gets the ESRB's panties in a bunch.
I still find it kind of odd how many 80s PG-rated flicks got away with stuff like "s**t" and whatnot. I think one of the oddest examples I've found thus far, though, and it's not a movie, is a recent sitcom called Men at Work, from TBS (Comedy Central airs it in Latin America) which gets away with, again, "s**t" as well as others like "a**hole", "d***head" and whatnot. I'm gonna take a guess on it being rated TV-14, tho.
As for ratings, I honestly think ESRB's at least changed a bit, 'cause you have something like The Witcher 2, which has some sex scenes (with full-frontal visible) and it still got an M rating, when other games that had such things (such as Indigo Prophecy/Fahrenheit and the original Witcher) got slapped with the AO rating.
An even weirder case of ratings, though, is with the recent iOS port of Carmageddon: the original was hugely controversial when it came out back in '97, it got censored in certain countries, and in others even banned. Apple's rating boards gave it a 12+. Not kidding. And you can run over pretty much anything on this, with gory details.
There's a decent documentary about the MPAA called This Film Is Not Yet Rated. Check it out if you want to hear about how much of a sham it is.
I saw that a few years ago. It's pretty good stuff.