Liking Firepower is totally logical! It's got a variety of good shots, gives you a reason to hit all of them, keeps you on your toes with those dangerous targets right in the middle, and rewards you with a blisteringly fast multiball. Oh and it's got a nice spinner. I'm curious what those who don't like it don't like about it. Too intense?
Dr. Dude, on the other hand, has three annoying shots you have to hit multiple times each just to grind your way to an anemic two-ball multiball in which you then have to grind another irritating shot repeatedly just to register a single jackpot. Also the theme is really obnoxious. : P
Genie is one of those tables where you really have to understand the rules to find the focus and the excitement--read the rules and you'll find that the way to survive is to take careful advantage of every feature on the table to keep alive by earning extra balls while maxing and then cashing in the bonus; get to the point where you need to make an EB shot or max bonus shot and you'll probably get some of that adrenaline pumping!
Added "Fish Tales." Time for you fishy fans to put your ratings where your mouths have been! : D
http://www.smbhax.com/tpatr/
It is, just on platforms neither you nor I have! : o
Heh. I'm with you on Cirqus Voltaire (plus the announcer lady is annoying, the table is set up really floaty, the ball lock detection is buggy (I'm told the real table has this problem too), the outlanes are set really cruelly low and wide, the backglass cannon thing is pointless, pretty nearly all you do is shoot the silly Ringmaster over and over, and the name is hard to spell : p).